Superman Returns.

I liked it.
zeGameboy liked it. zeWife and zeDad were "eh" about it.
I'll tell you what I need a Superman movie to contain: Superman doing the Crazy Impossible, and lots of it. So what did we get?
We got:
- Superman saving a falling plane and a flaming space shuttle AT THE SAME TIME.
- Superman getting shot in the eyeball by a bullet.
- Superman launching a continent made out of Kryptonite into outerspace.
What we didn't get:
- Superman punching the crap out of a giant robot.
- Superman taking on a mob of radioactive killer gorillas.
- Superman fighting with nunchuks.
But that's what sequels are for.